Dilema Facing Pope Francis -How to Clean up Augean Stables, his Church? Dr.James Kottoor



           “Harvest indeed is great but laborers are few,” said Jesus long ago. Now it is a question of a mammoth house cleaning work in progress for Pope Francis. Stewards he appointed are turning out to be turn coats and cheats, fit only for prisons. Any honest trustworthy guys out there? Only people with impeccable quality and credentials need to apply!

dr.james kottoor

       It is over one year since Pop Francis started out on a house cleaning operation at two levels: 1. First his own administrative offices in the Vatican. You have to lead by example, you have to become the change you want to bring about – so to drive home the idea of a poor church and simple life style, he said good bye to a palatial life of pomp and luxury, by living at St.Martha’s, a rented place and travelling in ordinary vehicles etc. 2. Second to get similar cleaning done in all episcopal headquarters around the world he exhorted them to introduce an inverted pyramid style of authority and administration (the whole Synodal speech of Oct.17th was about it) through two-fold dialogues – vertical and horizontal — in Church Citizens’ councils of clergy and laity at diocesan and parish levels.


Here we focus a little on the first point only. To clean up his administrative offices he can’t be everywhere in every room with a broom to sweep. He has to do it with a string of willing and honest deputies, collaborators, servants ready to do foot washing ministry like himself. But what happens if the one appointed as the store keeper himself/herself becomes a thief stealing from the store? This is the big question Pope Francis is facing and what the latest Vattileaks highlights: (Qui custodiet ipse custodes?) Who will guard the guards themselves? If the fence starts eating the crop what are you going   to do? If the pastors – Cardinals, Archbishops, Bishops and priests — start fleecing the sheep for profit or start butchering them to start or carry on their game or pass time of “flesh trade”(pun intended) how is he going to stop it?


   Europa Multiclub,

Europe’s biggest gay sauna?

We have heard of “Red light areas or streets” where sex trade is legalized. Of course, we have heard also people calling Rome the “whore of Babylon” but never thought they were referring to Vatican headquarters. But if we have to believe reports already published in www.Independent.co.uk, it is the first time we read explicit revealing accounyd of “red-light establishments…seedy saunas and massage parlors where priests pay for sex…. Europa Multiclub, Europe’s biggest gay sauna. Tales of visiting priests were legion, and a section of the sauna’s website promoting special “bear nights” included a video of a hirsute man stripping down and changing into a priest’s outfit” according to latest Vatican leaks.


That brings us to the unmistakable conclusion that the whole church — Cardinals, Bishops, Priests and Lay people — all are fully or partially involved in this sexy, financial scandal. Only we have to zero in now on the precise percentage of the involvement of the hierarchical church. Till recently these highly and heavenly placed celibate dignatories were fighting in the Synod about giving or denying communion to divorced and remarried lay folks, the vast, sprawling sinful lot. So with good reason we can now call ourselves, the whole Church, being full of (“Sancti Peccattori”) Holy Sinners. We heard it said first in the 2014 session of the Extraordinary   Synod. Therefore imagine how correct was Pope Francis when he described himself   at the very outset of his pontificate as “I am a sinner”. He knew already what kind of people he was going to deal with constantly. And he did not want himself to be superior to them in holiness, but equal to or below them to serve as a Servant of sinful servants around him.


You have to put a thief to catch a thief, it is said. By hook or crook, by accident or providential design, God has placed a humble, holy person as the servant of servants in his Church today. By calling himself a “Sinner” to start his mission he has expressed his desire to all that he does not want to be addressed as “His Holiness.” Thus Francis has taught the whole church one unforgettable lesson, namely: “No one born of man and woman has any right to point an accusing finger at any one of his brothers or sisters.” An opposite “better than thou” self adverting attitude will always turnout finally as an instance of “pot calling the kettle black”. No wonder a person like Elton Johson described him as: “Miracle of humility in an era of vanity!”

How could synod fail so Miserably?

Yet how is it that many of our so-called enlightened Synod Fathers have become so hard heartened and failed so miserably to grasp this central message of the Lord, first telling the crowd “Let the one without sin cast the first stone” and second to the woman caught in adultery: “I too don’t condemn you either. Go, sin no more”? Didn’t he also say: “I have come to save the sinners, not the saintly, the sick and wounded, not the healthy?” Did he not also present himself as the face of the prodigal father, the face of the good Samaritan nursing the victim of robbers? Again did he not tell the story of the unjust servant who got his debt of thousand bags of gold coins cancelled but would not write off a debt of 100 silver coins of his debtor, as an example of forgiving, not seven times, but seventy times seven?


In spite of all these towering, compelling, mind boggling examples of mercy, compassion and forgiveness how could these “Worthies — Eminences and Excellencies” act the way they did, like hard hearted, feeling less extortionists in refusing communion to divorced, or a gentle, welcoming word to lesbians? How could they have forgotten, that a betraying Judas, a doubting Thomas and a denying Peter were at the last supper and they all received communion from Jesus? Is there any instance in the Gospels where Jesus refused to forgive any repentant sinner?

Nay, is there any sin in this whole world which the Almighty cannot or will not forgive? If the Church in this world is not to project the tender heart and loving face of a Prodigal heavenly Father, what on earth is the very purpose for its existence? Oh tempora! Oh mores! Oh the justice and morality of these so-called hard hearted, Holy People in the Catholic Church! The earlier we burry this and other divided, fighting churches, the better it could be for the whole of humanity. That is why there is already a mass exodus from all churches, starting from the Catholic Church all over the world. What the world needs today is not a proliferation of churches but building up of a humane humanity beyond all churches and religions but taking inspiration from all.

Resurrect Humane Humanity

Pope Francis has been speaking often these days about this humane humanity. Jesus himself presented to the world more as the Son of Man – 85 times as against 38 times as the son of God – in the Gospels. I have been advocating this idea for some forty years, also following the example of Sri Narayana Guru, since the very purpose of Jesus’ mission was to clean up the whole of humanity drowning in dirt and filtgh and to domesticate it, that is, to make it shed its wild animal instincts to follow the rule of the jungle: “Might is Right.” So what is needed is a Jesus-like living to bring peoples of the world together as a family living in peace and harmony


To conclude on the theme we started with, commenting on denying a civilized welcoming language to lesbians and gay people, some one commented: “It is like inviting someone to your house for a dinner party and telling him/her on arrival, please don’t eat anything from the laid out table.” So think gentlemen, think. You don’t have to be a Cardinal, a Catholic or a Christian; you have only to be a gentle man to know what you should tell your invited guests to your party. The whole universe is God’s party laid out for you. Cultivate, produce, share and care, take and eat and drink from the sweat of your brow. Do not rust out but wear out!

                                                  Contact at: jameskottoor@gmail.com.


Mathew Idikkula, midikkula@yahoo.com, Nov.17/15

Dear BrotherJames,

I have read the above article fully and with close attention. You have voiced your concerns regarding today’s church loudly and effectively. I believe that the church is beyond repair.

The church was founded on untruth, has been propagating falsehood for the last two thousand years, and presently it  preaches and practices falsehood. The church can never guide people for the higher life standing from a lower life. It is an excellent article Jameschettan. Readers will be moved. Thanks.

Mathews, Chicago, usa


About The Voice Of Bombay's Catholic Laity

Bombay Laity Ezekiel’s Chapter 3 Task as Watchman 17 “Son of man, I have made you a watchman for the people of Israel; so hear the word I speak and give them warning from me. 18 When I say to a wicked person, ‘You will surely die,’ and you do not warn them or speak out to dissuade them from their evil ways in order to save their life, that wicked person will die for[b] their sin, and I will hold you accountable for their blood. 19 But if you do warn the wicked person and they do not turn from their wickedness or from their evil ways, they will die for their sin; but you will have saved yourself.
This entry was posted in Silenced Voice. Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Dilema Facing Pope Francis -How to Clean up Augean Stables, his Church? Dr.James Kottoor

  1. James Kottoor says:

    Dear Arcanjo, Many thanks for publishing it. Some of our elderly celibate prelates, I should have said many not some, are too harsh with weak hardworking lay people when they fail in matters sexual, but too lax with themselves indulging in sex. It is to force open their eyes I wrote it so that they may learn to imitate Jesus who never sent a repentant sinner empty handed with a heavy heart. I have also written a piece where I had to praise Cardinal Oswald Gracias, for his being in the forefront of the liberal group in being kind to lesbians. I want that also published in Bombay laity, so that he may see it. I have been harsh with him on other things but he should know I am also his admirer where he deserves it. Every devil should be given his due and we all have our devilish traits. Wish you all the best and God bless. james kottoor.

  2. The biggest abomination in the CHURCH clergy are the VERMIN who are the Diocesan / Secular clergy — They make up the most numbers — and they make / interpret the rules — and we HAVE TO OBEY —
    Sadly for them a JESUIT got elected to be POPE — they see it as a big travesty — since they are the most in numbers
    If this horrid loophole in our clergy system is abolished — then perhaps only those who REALLY
    wish to devote their lives to being SHEPHERDS instead of WOLVES — will only opt to be priests
    ALL CLERGY should take the three vows of ” POVERTY ” — chastity and obedience — not the present SHAM VOW that the diocesan / secular clergy take of chastity and ” OBEDIENCE ” —
    ODEDIENCE to who ????
    Then there will be a stop to all the money making tricks of this breed of VERMIN

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s